Skip to the stories
Electric Vehicles

Why James Hinchcliffe Saw Oscar Piastri’s 2026 McLaren Struggles Coming

  • Sean Fisher
  • 556 views

Hinchcliffe says Lando Norris had the edge after a close 2025, while Piastri faces a difficult reset at McLaren.

Why James Hinchcliffe Saw Oscar Piastri’s 2026 McLaren Struggles Coming

Oscar Piastri’s 2026 slump at McLaren looks less surprising to James Hinchcliffe than it did to many observers. The former IndyCar driver says Lando Norris had the edge entering the season, even after Piastri led the 2025 Formula 1 standings by more than 30 points. That judgment puts the focus on how closely matched the teammates were, and on how difficult a change in car regulations can make it to recover once a driver loses confidence and pace.

Piastri’s position changed sharply. A strong first half of 2025 had made him look capable of becoming McLaren’s leading driver, with Juan Pablo Montoya even predicting that he would “finish off” Norris. Instead, Norris won the championship, while Piastri’s season turned after a difficult weekend in Baku. His late-season form did not recover, and the problems continued into 2026.

Why Hinchcliffe gave Norris the edge

Hinchcliffe’s assessment wasn’t that Piastri lacked ability. Speaking on The Race F1 podcast, he called the Australian immensely talented and said he expects him to work through the difficulties. His point was that even top-level drivers can take time to adjust when a car doesn’t suit them. Being an F1 driver doesn’t make a setup or driving-style problem disappear after a handful of races.

“But for me, Oscar was the obvious one [to struggle],” Hinchcliffe said. Given how close Norris and Piastri had been the previous year, he said he would have picked Norris as the McLaren driver with the advantage going into 2026. That’s a judgment about the pairing and the competitive balance Hinchcliffe saw, rather than a claim that Piastri’s difficulties were inevitable.

The distinction matters. A championship lead at one point in a season can show a driver’s potential, but it doesn’t settle the internal contest for good. Norris finished 2025 as champion, while Piastri’s decline after Baku left him with less momentum entering a new technical era. The teammates were close enough that a modest shift in form or car fit could have a large effect on their relative results.

A difficult car adjustment with little time to spare

Piastri has said he is struggling for pace in McLaren’s 2026 car, and the team is helping him adjust his driving style. That work points to a practical problem: when a driver can’t extract the speed expected from a car, engineers and driver need to identify where the gap comes from and whether changes in technique can help. The source doesn’t specify the precise driving adjustments involved, so the key fact is that McLaren sees adaptation as part of the response.

Hinchcliffe’s comments also underline why a rough start can persist. A driver may need to change habits built around a previous car, while the team works to understand how the new machine responds. That takes time, and the process becomes harder to judge when a teammate is producing stronger results in the same garage. Each comparison can make the performance gap more visible, even when the drivers’ needs behind the wheel differ.

With three races remaining, Piastri is resigned to finishing eighth in the standings. That leaves little room to change the picture before the season ends. McLaren has also acknowledged that it started 2026 slowly after directing its resources toward winning in 2025. The team’s explanation gives the wider performance dip some context, but it doesn’t erase the individual challenge Piastri faces against Norris.

What Piastri needs from 2027

McLaren says its “Papaya Rules” are intended to prevent the team from favoring one driver as its internal number one. Results can still shape how the lineup is perceived: Norris’s stronger 2026 has put him in the leading position in the eyes of many observers, while Piastri needs to show that the gap can close.

The next season therefore carries weight beyond the standings. Piastri came close to the title in 2025, but he’ll need to regain form and beat Norris to re-establish himself as an equal contender within the team. McLaren is looking further ahead to 2027, when it hopes to return to more regular podiums and race wins, with an outside chance of a title challenge. Whether the team’s plans translate into a stronger car remains to be seen; for Piastri, the immediate task is to turn the help he’s receiving into pace.

Hinchcliffe’s read is a reminder that talent and recent results don’t guarantee the same trajectory when the car changes. Piastri has time to reset, but his 2027 performance against Norris will be the clearest measure of how well he has done it.

Source: Sean Fisher · www.f1oversteer.com

Neighbouring cells